We evaluated every tire on the market and cross-checked our results with real-world owners to find the quietest tires for Tesla Model S owners seeking a quieter ride.
Since its launch in model year 2012, the Model S has provided an excellent blend of high-level EV performance and minimalistic luxury.
But, many owners have complained about the road noise that the Model S produces with its stock tires from the factory, particularly the Michelin Primacy MXM4s found on 19 inch wheels and the Continental ContiSportContacts on the 21 inch wheels.
The issue gets worse as the tread wears down, and especially when driving on the highway.
Therefore, we sought out to find the quietest replacement tires for Tesla Model S drivers who want to upgrade their rubber.
We also confirmed our data and analysis with feedback from owners and online forums like Reddit and TeslaMotorsClub to validate our choices after they are actually used in the real-world.
Let’s check out what the quietest tires for the Tesla Model S are.
Please be aware that some of the links mentioned in this article are affiliate links, which means that we will get a small commission if you make a purchase through those links, but it will be no extra cost to you. Thanks for your support!
We also compared every online tire seller and found that Tire Rack consistently offers the best prices & free shipping (even directly to your installer). They also include:
• FREE 2 year Road Hazard Protection with no-cost roadside assistance
• Tire Replacement Benefit to reimburse you 100% of the price of a damaged tire up to $599 per tire
• Flat Tire Repair Coverage up to $40 per tire
• Mobile Tire Installation Service that can come to your house
• Fast shipping usually in 1 to 2 business days
We’ve never seen a more generous benefits package from any other retailer, so we added a link to Tire Rack for each tire below.
Quietest Tires for Tesla Model S – Background Research
To choose the quietest tires for the Tesla Model S, we first had to get an initial understanding of exactly how loud the stock tires that came with the car are.
Most 19 inch Model S cars were fitted with either Michelin Primacy MXM4 all-season tires or (from 2012 to 2020) or Continental ProContact RX all-seasons (from 2021 to present).
While these tires are generally quite competent, they were produced with an eco-focus in mind and not for overall comfort and quietness.
In fact, The stock Michelins only scored an 8.1 out of 10 for their road noise level, according to Tire Rack, while the Continentals received an 8.3 out of 10.
Those scores put them at the bottom quartile of tires regarding tire noise.
So, we sought out to find tires that scored at least an 8.5 or more, while also ensuring that they actually perform in all weather conditions as well.
Additionally, we made sure to find tires that offer long-lasting durability so that you get the best bang for your buck when selecting your next set of tires.
That also means that all of our choices are suitable for every trim of Model S made, including the Model S 60, P85, 70D, 85D, P85D, P90D, P100D, Performance, Long Range, and Plaid, and Plaid+ versions.
Best Quiet Tires for Tesla Model S – All-Season Tires
Vredestein Hypertrac All Season – Top Value Pick
Fits on:
19 inch (245/45-19)
The quietest tires for Tesla Model S owners just happens to also be the cheapest tires on this list as well.
Vredestein is a European brand that is starting to penetrate the US market by pricing their tires 40% to 50% cheaper than big brands like Michelin or Pirelli.
But, they actually offer premium performance levels (that are sometimes even better than the established brands).
These tires scored an 8.9 out of 10 for road noise and a 9.0 for their ride quality, according to Tire Rack.
Those are the highest scores out of any tire on this list.
But, they also offer top tier performance as well. In fact, these Vredesteins captured 3rd place out of 11 “Ultra High Performance All-Season” tires, leap-frogging big brands like Pirelli and Goodyear.
Vredesteins even offers a generous 8 year / 50,000 mile treadwear warranty (half the mileage if front and rear tires are different sizes).
Unfortunately, they are only made to fit on the standard 19 inch 245/45-19 wheels and not the larger 21 inch rims or 19 inch offset rims.
Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4
Fits on:
19 inches (245/45-19)
19 inches (front: 255/45-19, rear: 285/40-19)
21 inches (front: 245/35-21, rear: 265/35-21)
Michelin’s premium Pilot Sport All Season 4 tires offer a luxurious ride while also being able to handle virtually any weather condition.
They were rated an 8.7 out of 10 for road noise level and an 8.9 for ride quality by Tire Rack over 9.5 million miles of actual usage.
Yet, they still offer class-leading performance as well, earning a tie for 1st place out of 11 ”Ultra High Performance All-Season Tires,” with exceptional ratings for their dry and wet street performance.
Additionally, Michelin includes a 6 year / 45,000 mile treadwear warranty (half the mileage if front and rear tires are different sizes).
Continental ExtremeContact DWS 06 PLUS
Fits on:
19 inches (245/45-19)
21 inches (245-35-21)
Another great alternative for the quietest tires for the Tesla Model S is Continental’s top-of-the-line ExtremeContact series.
They earned an 8.7 out of 10 for their road noise along with a 9.0 for their ride quality on Tire Rack’s latest survey, scores that were gathered over 22 million miles of actual usage.
Additionally, they were rated as a tie for the #1 tire out of 17 other “Ultra High Performance All-Season Tires” by Tire Rack, which gives you an idea of how well-rounded these tires are.
Best of all, they cost a bit less than Tesla’s recommended original equipment tires.
Continental offers a 6 year / 50,000 mile treadwear warranty along with these tires as well.
Best Quiet Tires for Tesla Model 3 – Summer Tires
Michelin Pilot Sport 4S
Fits on:
19 inches (245/45-19)
21 inches (front: 245/35-21, rear: 265/35-21)
21 inches (front: 265/35-21, rear: 295/30-21)
If you want the highest performing summer tires (that also happen to have the lowest road noise), then we highly recommend these Pilot Sport 4S tires.
They are well-recognized in the automotive industry as the summer tire to get for class-leading handling, steering feel, and smoothness.
Their quality is reflected by their scores of 8.7 out of 10 for road noise and 8.9 for ride quality, which is head and shoulders above all other high-performance summer tires.
Their luxurious ride combined with their peerless performance abilities vaulted the Pilot Sport 4S tires to 1st place in the “Max Performance Summer Tires” category, according to Tire Rack.
Additionally, Michelin provides a 6 year / 30,000 mile treadwear warranty with these high-octane tires (half the mileage if front and rear tires are different sizes).
Bridgestone Potenza Sport
Fits on:
19 inches (245/45-19)
19 inches (front: 255/45-19, rear: 285/40-19)
We know the Michelins summer tires are quite costly, so if you have 19 inch tires on your Model S and are looking for something a bit more affordable (but still quiet), then consider Bridgestones’ flagship Potenza Sport line.
They earned an 8.5 for road noise level and a 8.7 ride quality, so they are quite quiet and smooth.
Yet, they also offer great performance in dry and wet conditions. Most notably, they scored a 9.3 for their dry performance along with a 8.9 for their wet performance.
Quietest Tires for Tesla Model S – Wrap-Up
We are confident that all of these tires will make your Model S ride a lot quieter compared to the stock tires that your car was shipped with.
There is really no wrong choice, as it will just depend on your climate and your budget. Either way, we believe that all of these tires will provide you with a great blend of quiet suppleness and crisp performance, making your Model S feel like a whole new car again.